The investigation uncovers that Michael Elkins was a chronically abusive father. The "ritual" elements at the crime scene were a staged attempt by Michael to deflect suspicion onto the local witch and protect his reputation. Michael eventually confesses, claiming he killed Cody in "self-defense" after the boy attacked him while trying to protect his younger brother, Brad, from further abuse. Key Character Moments
The CBI team is called to a small town to investigate the disappearance and subsequent murder of , a talented high school football star. Patrick Jane discovers Cody’s body in a wooded area, surrounded by candles and a pentacle, suggesting a ritualistic black magic sacrifice. [S1E12] Red Rum
Demonstrates his aptitude with children and his deep-seated disdain for bullies. The investigation uncovers that Michael Elkins was a
Provides comic relief through his unexpected superstition. Despite his stoic nature, he is genuinely unnerved by Tamzin Dove's "magic," leading Jane to give him a "protective" jar of ashes at the end of the episode to put his mind at ease. Key Character Moments The CBI team is called
is the 12th episode of the first season of The Mentalist , originally airing on January 13, 2009. Written by Andi Bushell and directed by Dean White, the episode presents a dark, suburban tragedy hidden behind the sensationalism of local witchcraft. Plot Summary
The primary suspect becomes , a self-proclaimed local Wiccan who had publicly "cursed" Cody after he allegedly tortured and killed her cat. While Cody's parents, Michael and Janice Elkins, are convinced of Tamzin's guilt, Jane’s observations of the family dynamics—particularly Cody's younger brother, Brad —suggest a different reality.
Reveals personal background, mentioning her father was a football coach, which gives her unique insight during the investigation into Cody's team and coach. Cast and Notable Guests