Critics and viewers alike noted the episode's successful balance of three distinct storylines:
Most User Reviews rate the episode highly for its "brilliant realism" regarding the psychological toll on police officers after a shooting. While the Danny/Gates case is played more for "comic relief," the Jamie and Frank segments provide the gravitas that Blue Bloods fans typically expect. "Blue Bloods" Fog of War (TV Episode 2020) - IMDb
Erin and Anthony clash over a case involving a citizen who shot two people in what he claimed was self-defense. This adds a moral complexity to the episode, especially as it pits Erin against the personal opinions of Mayor Chase. Community Feedback
“This is one of the top 3 shows of the entire series in my opinion. It has a little bit of everything... Near-Perfect episode.” IMDb
Danny and Baez team up with Waylon Gates (played by Lyle Lovett), a Texas Ranger hunting the "Lone Star Killer". Reviewers praised the "Texas vs. New York" banter, with Lyle Lovett’s "homespun Texas wisdom" serving as a great foil for Danny Reagan’s sarcasm.