If you need to write comments for a paper—whether you are a teacher grading a student’s essay or a peer reviewer evaluating a research manuscript—the best approach is to be constructive, specific, and balanced.
"There is a bit too much plot summary here; try to focus more on your own analysis." Recommended Comments
"The difficulty with this section is that it does not develop a clearly expressed thesis." If you need to write comments for a
"Moving forward, think about how this point connects back to your main argument." Recommended Comments
Focus on reinforcing what they did well while giving clear directions for improvement. "This is a very well-thought-out argument!" "You express your ideas so well in this section." "I love how you’ve used vivid language choices here." Constructive Critique: